Former Chairman of the Presidential Advisory Committee Against Corruption (PACAC), Prof. Itse Sagay, has cautioned against removing the proviso that allows manual collation of election results where electronic transmission fails, warning that Nigeria’s technological capacity is not yet foolproof.
Speaking in an interview with Daily Independent, Sagay argued that the Senate’s decision to retain both electronic transmission and manual backup is “more rational” and reflective of Nigeria’s current realities.
Sagay maintained that insisting on absolute electronic transmission without a fallback option could create avoidable crises.
“The Senate position, which is that there’s a proviso, is more rational, more reasonable,” he said.
He added that public distrust of the electoral system appears to be fuelling resistance to what he described as a balanced approach.
“Yet, because of suspicion, there is hatred of the rational position for what appears to be a little bit, what I would call a little bit irrational position,” Sagay stated.
According to him, technical issues may arise in certain areas, particularly remote communities, and such challenges should not automatically invalidate an entire election process.
“There can always be a little problem. It won’t be a glitch that will ruin the election. There could be a problem in a village or part of a town,” he explained.
The senior lawyer stressed that Nigeria’s technological infrastructure is still evolving and cannot guarantee seamless real-time transmission nationwide.
“It’s not because people are necessarily dishonest, but because our own level of technology is still not perfect,” Sagay said.
He acknowledged that past electoral malpractices have heightened public suspicion but urged Nigerians to allow “reason to prevail.”
“I think we should be a bit less suspicious even though we’ve had problems in the past and allow reason to prevail,” he added.
Sagay emphasised that ballot papers remain the foundational evidence of votes cast and would continue to play a key role even with electronic transmission in place.
“Reliance shouldn’t be placed on the counted ballot papers, which in the end is always the one that will still be used in counting. It will still be the main source. The electronic one will just be used to cross-check, to make sure that what is being counted by paper is not magic,” he stated.
He clarified that under the proviso, results would still be electronically transmitted, but manual collation would be permitted where technical failures occur.
“From what I’ve heard, I’ve not read it myself, the proviso is that it’s going to be electronically transmitted, but the actual uploading is going to be electronic. There’ll be room for manual collation in case there’s a problem. That is the main thing,” Sagay said.
Sagay warned that relying solely on electronic transmission could force electoral authorities to conduct fresh elections in areas where technical glitches occur.
“But what people are saying is that we should rely absolutely on the electronic transmission alone and nothing else. I think that’s a bit risky. Because if something goes wrong and you cannot go back on ballot paper, then you have to go and conduct a fresh election,” he cautioned.
He further noted that while ballot papers would still be counted in any case, disputes could arise where discrepancies exist between manual counts and electronically transmitted results.
“Where there is conflict between the ballot paper counting and the electronically transmitted one, the electronically transmitted one will prevail. I think that’s the position wanted by Nigerians,” he said.
However, he observed that some Nigerians insist that where electronic transmission fails, ballot papers alone should serve as valid evidence of the election outcome.
“The majority is saying that where the electronically transmitted one fails, then we only have the ballot paper. And that should be used as evidence of the election. And Nigerians are saying no,” Sagay added.